Sunday October 25th, 2026 - 9:00PM

New York Comedy Club Upper West Side 236 W 78th Street, New York, NY

Highly Suspicious is a stand-up comedy show with a twist: one comedian is secretly high, and it’s up to the audience to figure out who!
Featuring a lineup of some of New York City’s funniest comedians performing extended sets, Highly Suspicious combines great stand-up with a little mystery.

At the end of the show, audience members cast their votes for which comedian they believe is secretly high, guess correctly and you’ll win free tickets to a future show!

Come for the comedy, stay for the suspicion.

Featuring
Aaron Putnam
Zach Liss
Kerryn Feehan

Make Your Reservation

Please note you will need to show your Superfan Access Pass at the door for entry!

Requirements :

  • Your Superfan Access Pass will be required for admission.One per person. If you do not have a pass, or your pass is expired, you will need to buy a ticket to see the show
  • Please note that our $20 per person showroom minimum will apply to your visit. (includes drinks and snacks) – CT Tax and 18% gratuity additional
  • Please arrive 30 minutes ahead of show time
  • One Pass will admit up to 2 people
  • Individual comedian appearances subject to change without notice
  • If you have any questions, please email us at info@newyorkcomedyclub.com. Thank you!

ALL SALES ARE FINAL

Featuring

 

Kerryn Feehan

Aaron Putnam

Zach Liss